Thanks to the generosity of JTA (i.e. we could ride it free) and their likely desire to try and boost the image of the $ky-high-way, I took advantage of their opportunity, and made a rare ride on it today in conjunction with the Jazz Fest.
Here are some observations and experiences that convince me more than ever that this device is never going to succeed and should be terminated for good ASAP:
Yesterday we took the Jefferson Street Station entrance. The station, as I recall, lacked an escalator present in other stations. The stairs equate to probably a two and a half to three story house. On one side of the station was a pot hole filled dirt parking lot we happened to chose. Strangely, the entire edge of this lot fronting the station was cordoned off by 2 to 3 foot poles strung with heavy gauge wire that needed to be jumped or high stepped over. The entry to the station is confusing as there is metal fencing from floor to ceiling encircling it at ground level. At multiple places there are gated entries. But, for some reason some gates are open and others are closed so you have to circle around looking for the open entries. We found this same issue at the Hemming Park station. At Jefferson, once inside, one of two stairs was closed with yellow construction tape even though no activity was obvious. The other had tape but someone had broken through it so we used those steps.
At the turn stiles, it was hard to tell which ones were "exits", which were "enters", or which where two-ways. It was also hard to tell which were open for business and which were closed. Trial and error was the order of the day.
Arriving at the top, we noted that the vehicles don't carry any signage indicating their route designations or destinations. Rather, you have to look at a smallish little flashing sign board hanging from the station ceiling. The route board shows you can take a vehicle from Jefferson/Convention Center to Rosa Parks but that's not what was running. Instead, you could only go to the Central Station. There, you had to transfer to another vehicle only running from Central to Rosa Parks. Go figure.
Another annoying feature of the $ky-high-way is an ear-piercing warning device telling you to stand back when a train arrives. If that doesn't make a frequent rider deaf, or at least drive them to want to jump into the track out of being scared to death when it goes off, I don't know what will.
More problems inside the vehicles. If you are over about 6 foot, 6 inches, don't count on riding the $ky-high-way. That's about the maximum height in the vehicles. And, since the seating only holds about 6 men or 8 women, and the other 10 to 12 maximum riders are expected to stand holding poles, don't figure you are likely to sit. And, at this capacity, expect to just about be kissing your nearest passengers involuntarily as it's very tight.
In the vehicles, there are no visuals of the next stops or what route you are on, only a computer voice infrequently telling you what's next if you can hear it over people talking and are alert to the announcement being made. Don't know how JTA passed this by ADA requirements for hard of hearing and deaf people, but maybe since it is nearly riderless, no one bothers to care.
Today, we used the Convention Center station to start. This was slightly better since we parked in the JTA paved lot and it had an escalator. Again, the vehicle only went to Central and we transferred to get off at Hemming. I can assure you JTA succeeded in causing mass confusion with its ridership as many were seen getting on and off the wrong trains and trying to figure out what was happening.
The real fun came when the Jazz Fest ended and the $ky-high-way blew its chance to shine by carrying hundreds of riders in short order. It couldn't come close. The too-small platforms are quickly overwhelmed by a crowd approaching 100 riders. The two measly cars making up a vehicle were maxed out at typically about 18 to 20 riders. The crowd was once again mystified by the routing information and the actual routes running. The station signs also attempt to tell you when the next train is coming. Don't believe them. They are usually wrong. That will just leave you wondering if the train will ever come. And, tonight, it never did for one route. The train for San Marco had door problems or something and, with a full house in its cabins, just sat stuck at Rosa Parks while riders at Hemming were left to wonder what was happening, if anything.
Not seeing a train going toward Central or whatever in that direction, we boarded a train to Rosa hoping it would reverse itself in our favor. Our hunch was correct. It returned, already full to Hemming leaving more hapless riders there as we continued on, unable to add more passengers. At Central, we off loaded. After a repeat of trains never showing, despite the signs advising of impending arrivals, we were advised by the now present $ky-high-way SWAT team, that our train would be coming. It finally showed unannounced, and we boarded. And...the doors wouldn't close! Just like the Rosa Parks station train. After several attempts by the SWAT team, they instructed us to off load saying they had to take the train out of service. Now, it became evident that the $ky-high-way has another flaw - no side tracks. In other words, normal routing could not begin until this train was returned to home base. A SWAT team said the system was fully automated implying we had to wait until the computer realized what it needed to do to return this train home. That took at least 5 minutes after the SWAT team got the doors to close. At last, our train came in and we made it back to the Convention Center.
About that $ky-high-way ride: If you aren't sitting or strong on your feet, expect to hold on hard when standing. At the speed it travels around curves, it banks noticeably and you will have to work to stay perpendicular to the ground. Certainly, more effort than the much faster traveling NY subways. I don't see people with weak knees, bad ankles, sore hips, or the elderly finding the ride an easy one.
So, bottom line, I draw these conclusions:
1. No way the $ky-high-way is user friendly or comfortable.
2. It is very poorly routed/operated.
3. It is unreliable even when being showcased, supposedly at its best since its showtime.
4. It can no way handle more than a few people and would never work with a real rush hour crush, major events, or a bevy of conventioneers using it to return at once to downtown hotels. Forget about it ever being useful for Jaguar games or the stadium.
5. Communication between the system and its riders is most inadequate and unreliable.
6. Connectivity at street level is confusing and awkward.
I am more convinced than ever, after this $ky-high-way refresher, that this mode of transit is fundamentally flawed, beyond fixable, and not worth another cent of taxpayer dollars to keep running, much less expand it. It really is nothing more than what it was called when built, a small scale demonstration project, and a failed one at that. It will never have the capacity to carry enough people at once to make a dent in Jax transit nor will it ever achieve a competitive cost/benefit ratio.
While this is probably the most mundane of your concerns, the loud alarm you heard is sounded when a person moves a body part across the yellow safety line at the platform edge.
Quote from: Jim on May 30, 2010, 10:46:22 PM
While this is probably the most mundane of your concerns, the loud alarm you heard is sounded when a person moves a body part across the yellow safety line at the platform edge.
I get it. But, the NY subways carry tens of millions of passengers, and having ridden them extensively in the last few months, I can tell you they manage without such alarms (or even any railings), i.e. there has to be a better way or maybe JTA is being overly cautious or gratuitous.
I rode it both days I was at Jazz Fest, from the Southbank, and had no problems.
Oh, and I've ridden MARTA in Atlanta after major events, and it takes several trains - and theirs are long and big - to clear the platforms.
The Convention Center leg running in shuttle mode is curious. And you are aware the pot-hole filled Jefferson lot is privately owned, right?
Quote from: Charles Hunter on May 30, 2010, 10:53:40 PM
I rode it both days I was at Jazz Fest, from the Southbank, and had no problems.
Oh, and I've ridden MARTA in Atlanta after major events, and it takes several trains - and theirs are long and big - to clear the platforms.
The Convention Center leg running in shuttle mode is curious. And you are aware the pot-hole filled Jefferson lot is privately owned, right?
Charles, to each their own on the luck of the draw with the $ky-high-way working properly. My major points have to do with its infrastructure which is never-variable and inherent to the system. The comfort level, capacity, ride sensation, platform size, station design, communications of routes and arrivals, lack of side tracks for failed equipment, poor reliability, etc. are fixed in place or, after over 20 years, apparently incurable, and unlikely to be affordably and/or feasibly fixed at this point. These items, IMHO, add up to irrevocably doom the system.
As to your comparison to MARTA, or to go further, systems like the DC Metro, NY Subways, or the Bay Area's BART, we are talking apples and oranges. Those trains can move hundreds to a thousand or more per train. The Sky-high-way vehicles can move maybe 40 people in a perfect world. Yet, Municipal Stadium is just as big or bigger than the stadiums in those cities. So, if MARTA needs, say 5 to 10 trains to clear out a crowd, it would take hundreds of $ky-high-way trips. And, yes, Ock will say cars can be added. But, given the short length and size of the $ky-high-way platforms, the result won't change by much.
I figured the Jefferson lot was private but the $ky-high-way platform has a facing in its direction so I found it curious that side wouldn't be fully open. It's clear from the damage to the poles and wires that many have entered the station from the dirt lot over time. The least JTA could do is open gates on that side to make it easier to attract extra business, from whatever direction.
STJR, this is beneath you. Some people see only what they want to see. You claiming to offer a balanced unbiased "test" with your well known pre-conceived anti Skyway notions is comical. Your opinion is so prejudiced that you can't write "$ky-high-way" without your slanted opinion coming through.
I'd love to revisit your post perhaps tomorrow evening as I'll be out of town most of the day and see if we can make a balanced opinion of the performance of the SKYway.
OCKLAWAHA
Quote from: Ocklawaha on May 31, 2010, 01:21:55 AM
STJR, this is beneath you. Some people see only what they want to see. You claiming to offer a balanced unbiased "test" with your well known pre-conceived anti Skyway notions is comical. Your opinion is so prejudiced that you can't write "$ky-high-way" without your slanted opinion coming through.
I'd love to revisit your post perhaps tomorrow evening as I'll be out of town most of the day and see if we can make a balanced opinion of the performance of the SKYway.
OCKLAWAHA
Ock, shoot away. I never said anything about "unbiased" or "balanced", but most of my account is opining on facts I actually observed or experienced. You should be thrilled as that's actually "$ky-high" over (not "beneath") what is mostly posted here about the $ky-high-way. Of course, I am sure your "well known pre-conceived" pro $ky-high-way notions, that are just as comical :D to me, won't prejudice your opinionated response. ;)
Safe travels and we'll have some more "comedy" tomorrow. Too bad the taxpayers have to pay badly needed-elsewhere millions a year for the source of our "entertainment". ???
While I think the Skyway has potential, I agree it has many issues and there is room for improvement.
The comments by stjr appeared to go out of his way to complain.
If one doesn't like something, and wants everyone to know, then they will typically find everything wrong with it.
Of all the stations on the Skyway, Jefferson is probably used the least and vandalized the most.
I would ask stjr to try the Skyway during the next Gator Bowl parade and see if they have the same perspective.
JTA can make it run effectively, I have seen it. The Jazz Festival, while important, probably didn't rate so high as to warrant special attention. Unfortuntate, but a sign that it needs some strategic focus.
It seems to me that stjr is reporting his own personal experience with the Skyway. If Skyway is going to appeal to more riders and become an effective form of transit in Jacksonville, more work has got to be done on the very simple things that he reported. Why is that a problem?
Quote from: spuwho on May 31, 2010, 03:14:04 PM
While I think the Skyway has potential, I agree it has many issues and there is room for improvement.
To say the least!QuoteThe comments by stjr appeared to go out of his way to complain.
Hmmm... you weren't there, so how would you know? What did I point out that was "out of the way"?
I certainly found all the fellow riders I spoke with, or overheard, of a similar opinion to mine. QuoteIf one doesn't like something, and wants everyone to know, then they will typically find everything wrong with it.
If nothing was wrong with the $ky-high-way, maybe people would ride it. Proof is in the pudding. You can stick your head in the ground, but the problems are real and people notice. If you can't handle the facts, sorry. Wishing away complaints isn't going to make the $ky-high-way any more feasible.Quote
Of all the stations on the Skyway, Jefferson is probably used the least and vandalized the most.
If they open a station, take care of it. If they don't want to support it, close it. This is a lousy excuse for poor management. But, then, you only want to cover for JTA, not fix the problem, eh?QuoteI would ask stjr to try the Skyway during the next Gator Bowl parade and see if they have the same perspective.
Most of the issues I cited are "built in" and additional experiences aren't going to change them. Further, over the last few years on MJ, the operational issues have been consistently reported by less defensive posters. You can always say "try again" but most businesses don't rely on "second chances". They try, and need, to get it right the first time.QuoteJTA can make it run effectively, I have seen it.
Less than 99% reliability isn't going to cut it. Do you accept failure rates like this from your doctor, JEA, your car, internet or phone service, flying a plane, etc.? I don't think so. Lack of reliability is a sure course to failure. Once again, ignore the problem at your own peril.QuoteThe Jazz Festival, while important, probably didn't rate so high as to warrant special attention. Unfortuntate, but a sign that it needs some strategic focus.
If tens of thousands of local taxpayers downtown doesn't rate "so high", then what does? Just what does rate running the $ky-high-way? You are supporting my point that the answer is "not much", if anything. Thanks.Quote from: lindab on May 31, 2010, 04:25:41 PM
It seems to me that stjr is reporting his own personal experience with the Skyway. If Skyway is going to appeal to more riders and become an effective form of transit in Jacksonville, more work has got to be done on the very simple things that he reported. Why is that a problem?
Lindab, of course it's my personal experience. And, apparently that of many, many, others. It's a problem because the fixes are not "very simple" and certainly not cost effective. Reread my post and tell me how you cost effectively rebuild the stations larger, increase the capacity of the system, add sidings for inoperative vehicles without shutting down the whole system to clear the tracks, fix the quality of the ride or the seating and dimensions of the vehicles, or rebuild the automation system that fails to readily accommodate human intervention? Yes, the turnstiles, gates, and signage could be fixed, but even this may cost more than you would imagine. Why do think JTA hasn't already fixed it? By the way, even those "simple" fixes probably would cost far more than those extra bus shelters everyone wants. Wouldn't it be better bang for buck to build the bus shelters that JTA claims it can't fund if money is so tight?
Let's face it, there are a core group of $ky-high-way "lovers" here that are equally, or I dare say, more so, passionate about defending the $ky-high-way and overlooking its deficiencies, regardless of their significance. That's fine, but all that passion is not shared by the community at large and that's why, facts are facts, no one rides this and ridership has continuously declined over 20 years. Take off those rose tinted glasses and see this thing for what it is. We need to send it to the scrap yard so we can free up some $14 million a year for street cars and other superior mass transit solutions. Yes, that's my fact-based opinion (and lots of other citizens) and you are entitled to yours.
^^^ This. Is it the skyway fault? or the people who designed it.
Quote from: stephendare on May 31, 2010, 04:42:24 PM
STJR's observations are spot on, but I think his conclusions were foregone, rather than resultiing from.
Thanks for the charitable consideration, Stephen. :D I would only add no more foregone than the response in the works from Ock! ;)Quote4. It can no way handle more than a few people and would never work with a real rush hour crush, major events, or a bevy of conventioneers using it to return at once to downtown hotels. Forget about it ever being useful for Jaguar games or the stadium.
This is groundless. The cars fit together and can be expanded in order to accomodate more people. It will have to be expanded to allow longer trains to queue up, but that would be part of the actual line to the stadium.
Yes, I already acknowledged this forthcoming tidbit, once again, from Ock. But expanding the cars is limited to the size of the platforms and what I saw Sunday was just how small they really are, both in length, and capacity to hold much over 100 people safely. Short of massively rebuilding the stations, I don't see much more than an "academic" expansion of capacity.
Stephen, you also fail to consider that if the queue time is longer than alternative transit modes, including walking, what's the point of taking the $ky-high-way? There is a break even point here in terms of time and it appears to me to be far beyond the reach of this system under the best of circumstances. But, you are free to fantasize.
I remember when the opportunity to get federal money for transit other than buses came along. It was a "hurry-up and apply deal" promoted by Rep. Corrine Brown. The whole concept was have a transit system that wouldn't interfere with cars. Wow, what a concept.
lindab, if you're talking about the original Skyway money, Charlie Bennett was our Congressman. Was Rep. Brown in office for any of the Skyway expansions? I'm not sure, but don't think so.
Quote from: Keith-N-Jax on May 31, 2010, 05:18:49 PM
^^^ This. Is it the skyway fault? or the people who designed it.
Keith, in my mind, the "design," in this case, equals what is the Sky-high-way so not sure this distinction is important. But, the fact that similar people movers have failed in other cities to come anywhere close to expectations fully convinces me the concept is inherently flawed.
To your implied point of where final responsibility lies, I have to blame the owner/operator/project manager as the ultimate repository of responsibility, and that would be .... JTA. Kind of like BP and the oil spill. It wasn't their rig (Transocean's) and they were not the ones to cap the well (Haliburton) but it's their project and they have overall responsibility. And you see that in the views of the press, government, and the public.
Quote from: Keith-N-Jax on May 31, 2010, 05:18:49 PM
^^^ This. Is it the skyway fault? or the people who designed it.
or is it the people who continue to starve the system of needed operating funds (maybe in the hopes of runnjin the system into the ground)....and that is much larger than just JTA
While I agree with many of your points stjr your use of...
Quote$ky-high-way
Throughout your post lowers your credibility as an unbiased opinion of this flawed and mismanaged asset.
Quote from: stjr on May 31, 2010, 05:39:33 PM
Keith, in my mind, the "design," in this case, equals what is the Sky-high-way so not sure this distinction is important. But, the fact that similar people movers have failed in other cities to come anywhere close to expectations fully convinces me the concept is inherently flawed.
the Miami system does just fine (perhaps because it is directly connected to the Metrorail system) as do most of the airport systems....the concept is to provide a local circulator, nothing more.
We used the skyway last year for the Jazzfest. Unfortunately I am out of town this year... but we encountered many of the same problems stjr encountered... especially the confusing stations and locked gates. We actually had to hop the turnstyles to get up to the platform. Once there I used the customer service phone and was told they must have "forgot to unlock the gates! As for the cars being too small and people having to stand... this is pretty common on most modes of mass public transportation...
Quote from: BridgeTroll on May 31, 2010, 05:41:57 PM
While I agree with many of your points stjr your use of...
Quote$ky-high-way
Throughout your post lowers your credibility as an unbiased opinion of this flawed and mismanaged asset.
Bridge, point noted. I originally coined this term as a bit of pointed tongue-in-cheek play-on-words humor and have been surprised by how many are truly pained by it. I reuse it because I think it succinctly reminds us all about the bottom line: The system costs way too much both to build (as aptly noted by Stephen) and to operate to deliver so very little. A little subliminal effort to make my point seems harmless. Maybe I should trademark it ;) !
Tell you what, I will drop if for a little while and see if you are right though at times I might bring it up just to make the original point with an occasional "misguided" soul. Let's see if I get a more measured response. If nothing else, I'll spare myself some keystrokes ;)Quote from: BridgeTroll on May 31, 2010, 05:54:52 PM
As for the cars being too small and people having to stand... this is pretty common on most modes of mass public transportation...
Standing is not uncommon, agreed. But the ratio of seats to standing with the Skyway seems most unusual to me. It's over 2 to 1 standing by my count. I also find the height unusually low for a public space. How many 6 foot 6 inch ceilings have you seen in either a building or mass transit. Even the aisle of a plane has more head room. When the car is full, it's border line claustrophobic. Not to mention not much room for adequate ventilation above the head. By comparison, a crowded NY train looks downright luxurious.Quote from: tufsu1 on May 31, 2010, 05:40:14 PM
or is it the people who continue to starve the system of needed operating funds (maybe in the hopes of runnjin the system into the ground)....and that is much larger than just JTA
Name names, Tufsu. My understanding is the only other partner of note on funding the ongoing operation of the system is the City of Jacksonville, i.e. the same taxpayers rebelling against the City spending money on almost anything at present. Are you suggesting that COJ should put more in this system? While I support the COJ maintaining some level of a sustainable budget for our community at the possible personal expense to me of higher taxes, I could hardly support this given a long list of underfunded higher priorities as I see it .
Further, I don't agree that more operating funds will fix the Skyway given it has endemic infrastructure and conceptual issues. That's why I conclude we need to give up on it altogether. Failure is hard to accept but there is a time and place where it must be done to move forward and not spin wheels in the mud forever.
It will probably be able to handle the crowd tomorrow. Both of them...............
Names, names is Tufsu referring the tax payers on this one I am not sure. I think the blame totally on JTA and COJ. I say that because these two need to work and plan together. Stjr I really don't see how tearing the skyway down is cost effective Just MO anyway. As Tufsu mentioned the one in Mia works because its connected to metro rail and theres runs more extensively in their business district. We have had the Jags since 95, a new ball park and a new arena. Yet the skyway still doesn't service that area. The skyway services both bank N/S we need to take advantage of that, yet were not for what ever reason
Quote from: stjr on May 31, 2010, 06:52:47 PM
Name names, Tufsu. My understanding is the only other partner of note on funding the ongoing operation of the system is the City of Jacksonville, i.e. the same taxpayers rebelling against the City spending money on almost anything at present.
the list includes City Council members who don't want to spend a dime on the system...and people like yourself, who continually advocate for its complete abandonment.
bottom line, the system can (and will) work with appropriate funding...but ONLY if downtown becomes a desirable place to live, work, and play.
Quote from: tufsu1 on May 31, 2010, 09:15:11 PM
the list includes City Council members who don't want to spend a dime on the system...and people like yourself, who continually advocate for its complete abandonment.
bottom line, the system can (and will) work with appropriate funding...but ONLY if downtown becomes a desirable place to live, work, and play.
Tufsu, I think it's pretty clear that COJ isn't going to have the stomach to put more money toward the Skyway anytime soon. If we are going to do more to help downtown, we have far better ways to use the money. It's just the political and resource realities.
Do the streetcar and help both mass transit and downtown at the same time for less money. After 20 plus years, the Skyway has done nothing for downtown .... except, maybe damage it. Abandonment may be a bitter pill to swallow but that doesn't mean it isn't the best medicine.
I endorse streetcars for Jax....but you should know a few things:
1. I highly doubt they will be cheaper than the Skyway...remeber we're talking about $50 million to build a line from Riverside to downtown and $100+ million to build a system connecting Riverside, downtown, stadium area, and Springfield....the Skyway is already built!
2. Your concerns about quality of service could be experienced with streetcar too...its a matter of balancing supply w/ demand....take a look at Tampa....they now run one streetcar (holds less than 50 people sitting) every 15 minutes on the weekends and every 20 minutes during the week....even our Skyway does better than that!
I agree that political will and public sentiment is firmly entrenched in anti-skyway sentiments... can't say that I blame them.
I also agree that the times I have ridden the skyway, its confusing just to get on the damn thing... I have also experienced the turnstiles being closed on several occasions.
But, capacity can indeed be expanding as Stephen mentioned.... the Super Bowl was the best example. That thing moved some people that week.
Quote from: tufsu1 on May 31, 2010, 09:46:56 PM
I endorse streetcars for Jax....but you should know a few things:
1. I highly doubt they will be cheaper than the Skyway...remember we're talking about $50 million to build a line from Riverside to downtown and $100+ million to build a system connecting Riverside, downtown, stadium area, and Springfield....the Skyway is already built!
Tufsu, based on your logic, computers, cars, and planes would never get replaced even though they continue to function. But they do. And, the basis is cost/benefit. When you can get so much more benefit for each dollar of overall operating costs of your new investment over your present one, it makes sense to move ahead to something better.
Using your quote, and adjusting for inflation, building the streetcar system you advocate is a fraction of the cost of the Skyway. More importantly, it will carry many times the traffic for the dollar and this is what will pay back the "cost" to abandon the Skyway many times over. Most importantly, the streetcars will do for downtown development what the Skyway has failed to deliver on for decades and has no promise to do so. Add it up, and you have a compelling BUSINESS decision to make that involves walking away from a bad decision for a far better one.Quote from: tufsu1 on May 31, 2010, 09:46:56 PM
2. Your concerns about quality of service could be experienced with streetcar too...its a matter of balancing supply w/ demand....take a look at Tampa....they now run one streetcar (holds less than 50 people sitting) every 15 minutes on the weekends and every 20 minutes during the week....even our Skyway does better than that!
Tufsu, I agree, there is no limit to incompetency of management. But, all else being equal, I am convinced the streetcar will do far better than the Skyway. And, judging from the MJ pix, it clear there are streetcar models that equal or exceed the Skyway's capacity:(http://photos.metrojacksonville.com/photos/516077967_aCRYx-M.jpg)
stjr, but if the City does not provide adequate operating funds for the streetcar system, the situation will be the same - infrequent service, poorly maintained cars, which will lead to poor ridership, and people (maybe even you) complaining about the horrible cost.
Quote from: Charles Hunter on May 31, 2010, 10:14:18 PM
stjr, but if the City does not provide adequate operating funds for the streetcar system, the situation will be the same - infrequent service, poorly maintained cars, which will lead to poor ridership, and people (maybe even you) complaining about the horrible cost.
Charles, the likelihood of your scenario is greatly reduced over the certain financial disaster we have with the Skyway as the streetcars would cost less and produce more traffic from greater numbers using them creating a much more favorable revenue to cost ratio. And, additional property taxes from actual development along "improvement districts" lining streetcar routes could be channeled toward operating costs as well. Heck, maybe streetcars could actually come close to breaking even!
By the way, I would suggest that the inadequacy of operating funds is a "chicken and egg" issue. JTA (if I may actually dare come to their defense!) may see it as total futility to pump up the Skyway because they may have come to my conclusion, that it is a non-workable mode of transit. But, due to political realities, they may be fearful to admit such publicly. The best they can do is weasel out of it through "benign" neglect. Don't expect them to admit this but, sometimes, actions speak louder than words.
Quote from: tufsu1 on May 31, 2010, 09:46:56 PM
I endorse streetcars for Jax....but you should know a few things:
1. I highly doubt they will be cheaper than the Skyway...remeber we're talking about $50 million to build a line from Riverside to downtown and $100+ million to build a system connecting Riverside, downtown, stadium area, and Springfield....the Skyway is already built!
2. Your concerns about quality of service could be experienced with streetcar too...its a matter of balancing supply w/ demand....take a look at Tampa....they now run one streetcar (holds less than 50 people sitting) every 15 minutes on the weekends and every 20 minutes during the week....even our Skyway does better than that!
I like this, also keep in mind the skyway already connects the two banks together. I just needs to be completed. I just dont see how tearing it down is cost effective despite. Even in ATL the marta trains have problems with the gates and trains.
Miami's Metromover seems to work well with Metrorail. It averages 30,250 riders a day now. It will also be interesting to see what happens with Detroit's people mover when their proposed LRT line opens, connecting DT & the peoplemover to New Center.
At this point, I don't see how tearing the skyway down is a cost effective solution. The capital funds have already been spent to build the thing. Why not to find ways to better utilize and integrate the Skyway into the overall local transit network before giving up on it?
Quote from: thelakelander on June 01, 2010, 12:26:43 AM
Miami's Metromover seems to work well with Metrorail. It averages 30,250 riders a day now.
Lake, you didn't mention the Metromover is FREE in a city with several times our population. I think that makes the numbers suspect. It also runs a lot more frequently, for longer hours, and 7 days a week and has 29 stops in 4.4 miles which seems like a lot more per mile than we have. My question is what is 30K riders a day versus what was expected of it when it was built? Also, what is the proportion of tourists to locals? We have mostly locals so are locals users in Miami?
I think Miami's Metromover is a pretty good comparison. Miami's CBD suffers from many of the same problems as Jax as far as being a vertical office park. There aren't too many tourists in that part of Miami, so it's mostly locals.
The critical difference between the systems isn't the negligible fare or the hours of operation, (although I would agree that's something worth considering for Jax) It's that Metromover links with the TriRail commuter rail system. As opposed to the park-n-ride system in Jax. That's a big difference in arrival mode, and I believe that's what creates the major ridership differential.
Jax's skyway has some pretty serious flaws which have been cataloged ad-nauseum: bad route, crappy trains, awful guideways, no stadium, etc. However, if Jax did magically have a viable commuter rail system, it's easy to see how even our poorly designed skyway would be a success. Virtually 100% of the commuter rail riders would get off at a downtown/southbank station and then promptly ride the skyway to their building.
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/0f/Moscow_monorail001.jpg/800px-Moscow_monorail001.jpg)
Moscow Russia's new "Skyway" done RIGHT!It would be easy just to take issue with STJR over the JTA/Skyway perceived failures, however the failures are pandemic throughout Jacksonville transportation unless your last name is Goodyear or Gate. This is the first place where I split the hairs of blame, NONE of this is the fault of the Skyway-Monorail Design-Vehicles-Plant-Concept. Had this same project been tackled by a Chicago, Philadelphia or San Francisco, I dare say it would be humming along and chocking up thousands of passenger miles flawlessly. Building a system several times advanced from those in place in 90% of the world by a City that last saw mass transit in 1936 was a classic case of "sublime urban connector meets the Duke of Hazard."
Once again STJR has accused me of being a Skyway Defender, apologist and promoter and this is a record that needs to be set straight. I led the fight AGAINST the Skyway back in the 1980's even presenting my views and swaying the Jacksonville Journal under editor George Harmon to blast the plan with both barrels. Why? Because streetcars have made the most sense in the majority of Jacksonville transit solutions since 1870. I am also a realist, and our blind and deluded leadership went right off the cliff and built the Skyway after all. So nearly $200 Million dollars later, we need to assess the state of our transit infrastructure circa 2010 and carefully build from there.
As Abandonment would result in loss of premium above street-above traffic guide-way, and the new senate bill dictates that we MUST add to fixed guide-way mass transit this is not the time to turn and run. While some have pipe dreams of "futuristic monorail - Skyway trains" whisking Jaxon's from JIA to St. Augustine, the many drawbacks of monorails dictate a far more diminutive utilitarian role with the key word being connectivity.
So let's look at STJR'S points with a mind toward fixes rather then argue the systems validity and future based solely on it's heretofore mindless construction and mismanagement. Quote from: stjr on May 30, 2010, 10:28:19 PM
QuoteYesterday we took the Jefferson Street Station entrance. The station, as I recall, lacked an escalator present in other stations. The stairs equate to probably a two and a half to three story house. On one side of the station was a pot hole filled dirt parking lot we happened to chose. Strangely, the entire edge of this lot fronting the station was cordoned off by 2 to 3 foot poles strung with heavy gauge wire that needed to be jumped or high stepped over. The entry to the station is confusing as there is metal fencing from floor to ceiling encircling it at ground level. At multiple places there are gated entries. But, for some reason some gates are open and others are closed so you have to circle around looking for the open entries. We found this same issue at the Hemming Park station. At Jefferson, once inside, one of two stairs was closed with yellow construction tape even though no activity was obvious. The other had tape but someone had broken through it so we used those steps.
The stations are in poor repair and like the bus shelter issue, private-public investment might be the ticket to change. Wall's, gates, turnstiles, need to be taken down and the space opened up. Kiosk's for micro-businesses would provide a much needed purpose and alternate draw to vast empty spaces.
Quote
At the turn stiles, it was hard to tell which ones were "exits", which were "enters", or which where two-ways. It was also hard to tell which were open for business and which were closed. Trial and error was the order of the day.
(http://www.lvmonorail.com/buy_tickets/images/buy_tickets_main_photo.jpg)
(http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_uCvLpN_h81Q/SBaqK7X6BeI/AAAAAAAAAg8/qK3PBXyyP0Q/s400/skytrain+police+608.jpg)
Got Fare?
Turnstiles should be history the same as bus fair boxes, these systems have long since been retired from progressive systems. Fare, tickets, passes, day passes, discount cards, change and routing should be available from OFF THE SHELF vending machines, not only at the Skyway stations, but C-Stores, public buildings and larger stations throughout the JTA system. Fare is collected on an honor system, with roving transit police spot checking various routes and vehicles daily. Failure to have a valid ticket, results in a serious fine.
QuoteArriving at the top, we noted that the vehicles don't carry any signage indicating their route designations or destinations. Rather, you have to look at a smallish little flashing sign board hanging from the station ceiling. The route board shows you can take a vehicle from Jefferson/Convention Center to Rosa Parks but that's not what was running. Instead, you could only go to the Central Station. There, you had to transfer to another vehicle only running from Central to Rosa Parks. Go figure.
(http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3311/3284722851_7c35b77399.jpg)
This is the fault of the design of the junction of the Jefferson Street/Bay Street/Riverplace lines. Laid out correctly (model train 101) would have one route operating end to end from Jacksonville Terminal to Rosa Parks
and another from Kings Avenue to Central. These cars would NEVER normally cross each others routes. With short expansions to provide populated destinations, the Kings Avenue-Central route could be extended endlessly Eastward, or Southward and the Terminal-Rosa Parks could be extended Northward and Westward. Signage in the form of electronic destination curtains is something we should look into, as well as station name signage over the ends of the station roofs in plain view, visible from approaching or departing trains (see photo).
QuoteAnother annoying feature of the $ky-high-way is an ear-piercing warning device telling you to stand back when a train arrives. If that doesn't make a frequent rider deaf, or at least drive them to want to jump into the track out of being scared to death when it goes off, I don't know what will.
Touching that 3Rd Rail down on the side of the concrete beam will NOT scare you to death, rather you will instantly be Shocked to death, and left as a smoldering mass of burnt flesh. 600 VOLTS DC is not to play with, and it is the EXACT same current used on Streetcars. The warning device JTA has invested in is very advanced and frankly rather unique if not completely warranted by the lack of transit experience of our average citizens.
This system sounds the alarm when anyone steps or leans beyond the traditional yellow warning line, moreover, it CUTS THE POWER to the track, kills the 3Rd rail in that area and sets the brakes on the train. Back off and everything goes back to normal.
QuoteMore problems inside the vehicles. If you are over about 6 foot, 6 inches, don't count on riding the $ky-high-way. That's about the maximum height in the vehicles. And, since the seating only holds about 6 men or 8 women, and the other 10 to 12 maximum riders are expected to stand holding poles, don't figure you are likely to sit. And, at this capacity, expect to just about be kissing your nearest passengers involuntarily as it's very tight.
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/4c/Moscow_Monorail,_Ulitsa_Sergeya_Eizenshteina.jpg/800px-Moscow_Monorail,_Ulitsa_Sergeya_Eizenshteina.jpg)
Moscow's wide open platforms, no gates, no walls, no turnstiles...
The cars are small with a capacity of just over 20 persons each, newer equipment can allow for walking from car to car within the train, fold down seating and MUCH larger passenger capacity. There are over a dozen manufacturers that could fill our order. We also own the rights to the larger center cars of the current trains but we have never ordered them. As currently laid out 4 center cars could be added raising the per train capacity from the current 40 m/l passengers to 160 m/l. A vestibule equipped train that allowed for walk-through's could go longer and larger without having to extend the platforms.
QuoteIn the vehicles, there are no visuals of the next stops or what route you are on, only a computer voice infrequently telling you what's next if you can hear it over people talking and are alert to the announcement being made. Don't know how JTA passed this by ADA requirements for hard of hearing and deaf people, but maybe since it is nearly riderless, no one bothers to care.
Visuals should make a difference, destination curtains as well as depot identification signs would go a long way toward making this friendlier. Going a step further, the ENTIRE SYSTEM should have multi-lingual signage this should include our port terminals, airport, Jacksonville Terminal, bus, Skyway, River Taxi, Streetcars and Commuter Rail, with a local ordinance that forces similar placards to be placed in taxi's, jittney's, etc...
Quote
Today, we used the Convention Center station to start. This was slightly better since we parked in the JTA paved lot and it had an escalator. Again, the vehicle only went to Central and we transferred to get off at Hemming. I can assure you JTA succeeded in causing mass confusion with its ridership as many were seen getting on and off the wrong trains and trying to figure out what was happening.
The real fun came when the Jazz Fest ended and the $ky-high-way blew its chance to shine by carrying hundreds of riders in short order. It couldn't come close. The too-small platforms are quickly overwhelmed by a crowd approaching 100 riders. The two measly cars making up a vehicle were maxed out at typically about 18 to 20 riders. The crowd was once again mystified by the routing information and the actual routes running. The station signs also attempt to tell you when the next train is coming. Don't believe them. They are usually wrong. That will just leave you wondering if the train will ever come. And, tonight, it never did for one route. The train for San Marco had door problems or something and, with a full house in its cabins, just sat stuck at Rosa Parks while riders at Hemming were left to wonder what was happening, if anything.
Not seeing a train going toward Central or whatever in that direction, we boarded a train to Rosa hoping it would reverse itself in our favor. Our hunch was correct. It returned, already full to Hemming leaving more hapless riders there as we continued on, unable to add more passengers. At Central, we off loaded. After a repeat of trains never showing, despite the signs advising of impending arrivals, we were advised by the now present $ky-high-way SWAT team, that our train would be coming. It finally showed unannounced, and we boarded. And...the doors wouldn't close! Just like the Rosa Parks station train. After several attempts by the SWAT team, they instructed us to off load saying they had to take the train out of service. Now, it became evident that the $ky-high-way has another flaw - no side tracks. In other words, normal routing could not begin until this train was returned to home base. A SWAT team said the system was fully automated implying we had to wait until the computer realized what it needed to do to return this train home. That took at least 5 minutes after the SWAT team got the doors to close. At last, our train came in and we made it back to the Convention Center.
There is no excuse for this! The system is hardly the "fully automated" wonder we are told about, in fact it has two very real human operators back at the Skyway operations center, armed with over 100 camera views of every inch of the property. The Skyway systems DOES have a diesel switcher s well as a host of sidings at the home base. Each car can also be operated manually from the dashboard control panel that is hidden in the end of each car under the locked cabinet.
Quote
About that $ky-high-way ride: If you aren't sitting or strong on your feet, expect to hold on hard when standing. At the speed it travels around curves, it banks noticeably and you will have to work to stay perpendicular to the ground. Certainly, more effort than the much faster traveling NY subways. I don't see people with weak knees, bad ankles, sore hips, or the elderly finding the ride an easy one.
(http://foto.rambler.ru/public/vladorlando/7/503326/503326-webbig.jpg)
Moscow, Russia
The Skyway is rougher then steel wheel on steel rail technology, but still smoother then a city bus with the cheap air bag suspension. It makes up for it's discomforts by "flying" over the traffic.
Every one of the conclusions are fixable and with some creativity, the Skyway could assist in paying US to fix it!
OCKLAWAHA
Quote from: Jim on May 30, 2010, 10:46:22 PM
While this is probably the most mundane of your concerns, the loud alarm you heard is sounded when a person moves a body part across the yellow safety line at the platform edge.
Exactly....this topic is comedy
Quote from: Charles Hunter on May 30, 2010, 10:53:40 PM
I rode it both days I was at Jazz Fest, from the Southbank, and had no problems.
Oh, and I've ridden MARTA in Atlanta after major events, and it takes several trains - and theirs are long and big - to clear the platforms.
The Convention Center leg running in shuttle mode is curious. And you are aware the pot-hole filled Jefferson lot is privately owned, right?
Gotta co sign the lot thing and the Marta thing. They run 3 cars each car equal 5 Skyway cars and after events its more standers than sitters. Glad the Skyway was over packed this weekend that is beautiful news.
Quote from: lindab on May 31, 2010, 04:25:41 PM
It seems to me that stjr is reporting his own personal experience with the Skyway. If Skyway is going to appeal to more riders and become an effective form of transit in Jacksonville, more work has got to be done on the very simple things that he reported. Why is that a problem?
Its an issue because of the topic starter. This site is pro transit, pro walkability, pro bikeability. Right now the Skyway is the Jacksonville train system. Many know the truth that its about 8 stations short of being a complete system. The real question is what is trolling? Everyone know what The Issue is with the Skyway & its lack of milege. Im glad someone took pictures of the Jazz Fest. It proves the point that the Skyway is an asset. Take the Skyway away and where do all those people park? If people cant park n ride they go back home and they dont spend cash downtown aka The BIG PICTURE. Make matters worse the Northsiders dont even have a park n ride like Terminus, Jefferson & Kings Ave....8 stations, people can only park at 4 of them. Finish it & educate the public. nuff
Quote from: BridgeTroll on May 31, 2010, 05:41:57 PM
While I agree with many of your points stjr your use of...
Quote$ky-high-way
Throughout your post lowers your credibility as an unbiased opinion of this flawed and mismanaged asset.
I see it as an asset, that should be finished. Never heard someone say they could not find the entrance or exits, pot holes in parking lots, safety sensers being crossed, not wanting to stand on a train, stations not having escalators?? Lol its nitpicking.
MY Issue The Routing is the fault of JTA, I bet they had no clue The Jazz Fest would be well attended, because simple math would tell you the train that starts at Terminus & King Ave should ride all the way to Rosa Parks station...there shoul be no transfer at Central. Which means they were on regular weekend schedule. The Skyway has problems because the firm that runs it has problems. Trouble finding a seat, finding an exit/entrance, needing escalators is not a legit issue. I was just in Chicago I got lost on their system a few times. It was my fault for not knowing the system not the El Train. Now if I live in Chicago Id learn the system way before going to an event via transit. I mean the topic starter is a Jax resident and doesnt know the Skyway system??? Thats not even JTAs fault thats his. He doesnt know the system because he doesnt use the system. Then bashes the system because its not the NY Subway? Ha ha ha ha ha ha....I dont believe you actually even rode the New York system or Chicago, you have no proofof actually riding those systems. His post are so Anti Transit its funny....the whole Sky HIGH way thing is just another form of trolling....lol hes a transit troll wow. Lets get a Skyway Sucks thread from Steve or Lake or one of the pub crawl ladies or someone else....its the same old thing from the same old guy. A guy who does not even use it. I mean dude you got lost at Jefferson Station? ha ha ha ha....really? Jefferson Station? Exolain that one for me?
Quote from: Keith-N-Jax on May 31, 2010, 11:49:00 PM
Quote from: tufsu1 on May 31, 2010, 09:46:56 PM
I endorse streetcars for Jax....but you should know a few things:
1. I highly doubt they will be cheaper than the Skyway...remeber we're talking about $50 million to build a line from Riverside to downtown and $100+ million to build a system connecting Riverside, downtown, stadium area, and Springfield....the Skyway is already built!
2. Your concerns about quality of service could be experienced with streetcar too...its a matter of balancing supply w/ demand....take a look at Tampa....they now run one streetcar (holds less than 50 people sitting) every 15 minutes on the weekends and every 20 minutes during the week....even our Skyway does better than that!
I like this, also keep in mind the skyway already connects the two banks together. I just needs to be completed. I just dont see how tearing it down is cost effective despite. Even in ATL the marta trains have problems with the gates and trains.
Keith man on some days the Marta is crap, because of Marta, City of Atlanta & the state of Georgia. Ive been to stations were the gates had no power supply....you tap the breeze card and nothing. We are trapped in the station until they turn the gates on. At lease with Jta you can jump the turnstyle lol. Then they have this thing called one tracking...OMG when they do that you have to wait an hour for a train if your at the end of the line. We recently had an issue where the company that maintains the elevators n escalators did some bad wire work and Marta ended their contract, shut down all escalators at ll 38 stations include Peachtree Center!! And you know how deep underground that station is. So I agree with your point. I was in Chitown...they had a few issues on their train...and as I mentioned some of it was my lack of knowledge...do I want Marta to shutdown because of the issues? hell no, how self centered & self rightous is that? The Skyway is an amenity. Over built, but still started and needs to be completed.
Quote from: stjr on June 01, 2010, 12:41:24 AM
Quote from: thelakelander on June 01, 2010, 12:26:43 AM
Miami's Metromover seems to work well with Metrorail. It averages 30,250 riders a day now.
Lake, you didn't mention the Metromover is FREE in a city with several times our population. I think that makes the numbers suspect. It also runs a lot more frequently, for longer hours, and 7 days a week and has 29 stops in 4.4 miles which seems like a lot more per mile than we have. My question is what is 30K riders a day versus what was expected of it when it was built? Also, what is the proportion of tourists to locals? We have mostly locals so are locals users in Miami?
Everything you mention above is an example of better utilizing an existing asset before pulling the plug. You've basically proved my point. Make it more user friendly (better transit connectivity, frequency, access, etc.) and ridership will dramatically increase.
Quote from: Joe on June 01, 2010, 01:03:52 AM
I think Miami's Metromover is a pretty good comparison. Miami's CBD suffers from many of the same problems as Jax as far as being a vertical office park. There aren't too many tourists in that part of Miami, so it's mostly locals.
The critical difference between the systems isn't the negligible fare or the hours of operation, (although I would agree that's something worth considering for Jax) It's that Metromover links with the TriRail commuter rail system. As opposed to the park-n-ride system in Jax. That's a big difference in arrival mode, and I believe that's what creates the major ridership differential.
This is the major difference. Between Metrorail and Tri Rail, you have 93.3 miles of fixed transit directly connecting the Metromover with other communities like Hialeah, Kendall, Coral Gables, Hollywood, Fort Lauderdale, Pompano Beach and West Palm Beach. As of 2008, those systems had a combined 83,100 riders a day, with direct access to the Metromover. If you ever want to see the benefit of transit integration, hop on the Metromover before and after Miami Heat basketball games. People leave their cars in the burbs, hop on Metrorail and pour onto the Metromover to get within a block of the arena. My guess is once the Metrorail extension to the airport is complete, they'll see another boost in Metromover's ridership numbers.
While I would not endorse spending a ton of money extending the skyway at this point, I'm a huge fan of better integrating it with the existing bus system and future commuter rail and streetcar lines.
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/55/Government_Center_from_Cultural_Center.jpg)
Government Center Station is Miami's central metro station, as well as Downtown Miami's main station. Transfers can be made to all three Metromover loops and all intercity Metrobus lines.QuoteJax's skyway has some pretty serious flaws which have been cataloged ad-nauseum: bad route, crappy trains, awful guideways, no stadium, etc. However, if Jax did magically have a viable commuter rail system, it's easy to see how even our poorly designed skyway would be a success. Virtually 100% of the commuter rail riders would get off at a downtown/southbank station and then promptly ride the skyway to their building.
So true. Ironically, this concept was a part of the original vision for the skyway in the first place.