Tampa thinks CSX/Orlando commuter rail deal sucks

[thelakelander]

Orlando's neighbor down the street believes it is getting screwed in the deal to put commuter rail in Mickey Mouse land.

Last Stop In Rail Plan: Tampa

Lindsay Peterson and Billy Townsend / Tampa Tribune

Published: September 8, 2007

Special Report

Gov. Jeb Bush and the chief of CSX Transportation, Michael Ward, emerged from the sleek new commuter train in Orlando to trumpet their landmark deal.

That morning, Aug. 2, 2006, they announced a plan to bring long-awaited commuter rail to Central Florida. CSX would get nearly a half-billion dollars in tax money for the sale of its Orlando area track and upgrades on its freight lines into a massive hub planned for Polk County.

The event highlighted the 61-mile passenger system that would take hundreds of cars off of crowded Orlando roads. But no one mentioned the larger plan behind the deal - a plan that could prevent the creation of passenger rail for the rest of Florida. It puts freight rail companies in control of where passenger lines will go and how much they will cost the taxpayers.

CSX is the winner in its deal with the state, critics say.

"Jeb set this thing up," said Gus Demott, of the Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen, who has been looking at the deal to assess how it will affect the union's members. One thing he believes: "Once this deal is done, it's going to be a windfall for CSX."

The likely loser is the Tampa Bay area, particularly Lakeland.

Under the state's new plan, commuter rail isn't likely to come to Tampa for decades - if ever - because of CSX's plans for unlimited freight increases in the area. That freight traffic will be routed through downtown Lakeland, where local officials fear years of expensive redevelopment efforts will be ruined.

Bush has defended the CSX deal as a strong public-private partnership. It would help both the people of Florida and the freight companies, which he said were vital to the state's economy.

But an analysis of the costs and benefits of the deal has not been finished, so state officials don't know whether taxpayers will come out ahead. Significant pieces of the agreement haven't been settled.


Who's Helping Whom?

From the start it was an effort to help the freight railroads, said C.C. "Doc" Dockery, who led an earlier effort to create a statewide passenger rail system. That system would have started with the 84-mile corridor from Tampa to Orlando, which is the state's busiest.

Passenger rail that would take the most cars off the roads is being "abandoned in favor of speedier movement of rail freight," Dockery said in an interview last month. "A good decision for the people? No. A good multimillion-dollar decision for the special interests represented by CSX? Yes."

Ward, CSX's CEO, turned down interview requests.

Dockery is a Lakeland businessman whose efforts to build a high-speed rail system in Florida date to the late 1970s. He envisioned trains traveling more than 120 mph on new tracks connecting metropolitan areas. The existing freight tracks don't allow for speeds that high.

He helped write the constitutional amendment that voters passed in 2000, which mandated such a plan.

The Florida High Speed Rail Authority had written specifications, solicited bids and selected a company to build the Tampa-to-Orlando link when voters repealed the project with another constitutional amendment in 2004.

Bush helped lead the campaign against high-speed rail, arguing that the system would bankrupt the state. Among the many corporations that contributed to the cause, CSX gave $50,000 and Florida East Coast Industries gave $25,000. Florida East Coast owns a rail line that runs from Jacksonville to Miami.

Even before he began his public fight against the bullet train, Bush was looking for a way to help the freight rail companies, Dockery said.

"Jeb's intentions to reward his friends at CSX and FEC surfaced early when he appointed FEC Vice President Heidi Eddins to the Florida High Speed Rail Authority," Dockery said.

During meetings, "she aggressively argued that the state should take an incremental approach to building high-speed rail, meaning we should use existing rail freight lines owned by CSX and FEC."

A spokesman for FEC didn't respond to requests for interviews with Eddins and other executives.

In early December 2004, a month after Florida voters repealed the bullet train amendment, CSX officials visited the state Department of Transportation. The company, based in Jacksonville, unveiled a new business strategy for Florida. It planned to reroute its freight traffic from a line that ran into Orlando onto a parallel line that ran into Polk County, where CSX also wanted to build a major hub.

The plan had a side benefit for the state. It would open up track in the Orlando area for commuter rail.

Then-DOT Secretary Jose Abreu said he jumped at the chance to talk. "Here was an opportunity where they [CSX] are saying maybe it is time to get together with DOT," he said. "Before that, if you tried to talk to the railroads, it was like beating your head against the wall."

In the summer of 2005, Bush appointed a new DOT secretary, his chief of staff, Denver Stutler. Abreu said he left because he was offered a job in his native Miami, running the international airport.

The plan that Stutler's DOT developed over the next few months was almost identical to the one CSX had presented in 2004.

The state would help CSX upgrade its freight line running south through west Central Florida into Polk County so the line could handle more trains. It would pay for road access to a new hub planned for Winter Haven, which the state later dubbed "the mother of all rail yards." And the state would buy 61 miles of track on the line into Orlando for a commuter rail system.

The plan came together in negotiations that stretched into 2006. It involved only CSX officials and a handful of DOT staff members and consultants, all of whom were required to sign confidentiality agreements.

Months later, at a Florida Transportation Commission meeting, Stutler said the governor had asked often about the progress of the CSX deal. He said his relationship with Bush helped him fend off "ankle-biters." Asked by the Tribune to whom he was referring, Stutler said he couldn't remember.

Bush declined an interview, referring comment to his spokeswoman, Alia Faraj. She defended the governor's opposition to the high-speed rail plan and his advocacy for the CSX plan that followed.

"The bottom line is the governor made decisions based on good public policy implications," Faraj said.


New Plan Puts Tampa At Bottom

In August 2006, the same month the state and CSX announced the outline of their deal in Orlando, the state released its Florida Intercity Passenger Rail Vision Plan.

Like the agreement announced in Orlando, it closely follows the plan CSX presented in December 2004.

Contrary to the Florida High Speed Rail Authority's plan, it describes a passenger system built on existing corridors, nearly all of which are owned by CSX or FEC. It's the incremental approach, the type FEC's Eddins advocated, Dockery said, when she was on the authority.

It shows that the busiest stretch of highway is between Tampa and Orlando, with people expected to take nearly 30 million trips between the two areas in 2020 - double the number in 2000.

And it presents a connection between the two cities by CSX's rail line south of Interstate 4. But there's a catch: CSX doesn't want a passenger system on that line.

Because of increased train traffic around the Polk County hub, CSX feels "reluctance" to allow any passenger service between Auburndale and Tampa, according to the report.

DOT rail manager Fred Wise put it more bluntly: CSX "won't even discuss it."

CSX spokesman Gary Sease said the company hasn't been approached with any commuter rail idea for its Auburndale to Tampa line, which runs through Lakeland. But he said CSX's first priority is expanding its freight business.

"The addition of commuter rail to our freight tracks diminishes our ability to do that," Sease said.

The only other way to have a Tampa-to-Orlando rail link is to build tracks on the I-4 right of way, as the High Speed Rail Authority had planned. But that would come only after the state had used nearly every available CSX and FEC line, according to the new passenger rail plan. In other words, the top priority of the High Speed Rail Authority is now one of the state's lowest priorities, even though the state already owns the right of way.

Bush and CSX say the high-speed rail plan was too expensive, a boondoggle that would have cut into the state's ability to provide vital services, such as education. Yet documents show the state has pursued buying 85 miles of FEC's rail line in South Florida to use for a new commuter rail service. DOT officials estimated last year that the entire project could cost $3 billion, possibly more.

The 84-mile Tampa-Orlando rail link was projected to cost $2.4 billion. Stutler said last month that the two projects aren't comparable because federal money would pay for half the project in South Florida. But the federal government had also contributed half of the money for high-speed rail planning, and backers were optimistic that the federal government would fund at least a third of construction costs, Dockery said.

Asked whether Orlando-style commuter rail deals are likely for other cities, Stutler responded: "That's a great question." He didn't mention any possibilities beyond FEC's South Florida line. Talks between the state and FEC were put on hold this year when FEC was sold to a group of private equity investors.


'It's All Politics'

When Marion County officials heard about CSX's realignment plan just before it was announced in August 2006, they were furious. They demanded to know what the state would do to protect residents from the rising number of trains that would be moving through Ocala.

Lakeland and Polk County officials were slower to react. Winter Haven officials strongly support the hub and distribution center that would be built with it because they would bring new tax money and up to 2,000 jobs. But roads outside the city, such as State Road 60 and U.S. 27, would absorb most of the trucks driving in and out of the facility - an estimated 1,000 trips per day.

CSX's plan will add trains to the stretch of track between Plant City and Lakeland on which six people have died in three months in vehicle collisions with Amtrak passenger trains.

In the thousands of DOT e-mails and documents reviewed for this story, there were few references to safety improvements in the CSX deal. At the same time, however, internal e-mails show that state rail inspectors expressed serious concerns about CSX's commitment to safety, particularly in the Lakeland area.

"CSX Transportation needs to somehow get the message that we need them to step up to the task at hand," inspector George Nobles wrote on Oct. 27. "They are not trying to properly maintain the current traffic demands and will degrade even more as traffic is increased."

Contacted for this story, Nobles said safety conditions had improved since that e-mail.

CSX said it had only one reportable accident related to its equipment or tracks in 2005 and 2006.

DOT's Wise said safety was discussed during negotiations.

Officials in Lakeland have their own worries about more train traffic. CSX's freight line bisects the core of the city. Several north-south roads are already shut down several times a day for trains.

CSX officials have talked to Lakeland officials but offered no remedy.

The company is a "500-pound gorilla on steroids," said Lakeland Commissioner Dean Boring.

"It's all politics, and it stinks to high heaven," said Marion County Commissioner Jim Payton.

The company has spent hundreds of thousands on lobbyists and campaign contributions in Florida.

One CSX lobbyist, Marty Fiorentino, is a former CSX executive who was named a Bush Pioneer for raising at least $100,000 for George W. Bush's 2000 presidential campaign.

Fiorentino and his wife have contributed to Jeb Bush's campaigns, too, giving $3,000 in Bush's two races since 1997. Ward, the CEO, has given $1,000. And companies owned by CSX have given $2,000.

Overall, CSX has doled out nearly $1 million to candidates and committees in the past 10 years in Florida, including $494,000 to the Republican Party.

"CSX has the influence," said state Rep. Susan Bucher, a West Palm Beach Democrat on the Transportation Committee.


Working Out The Details

Ward wanted something from Bush in the days after the Aug. 2, 2006, gathering in Orlando. They had announced only an agreement in principle. Ward reminded Bush in an e-mail that many details had to be worked out.

Before suggesting that he and Bush get together for another round of golf, Ward said, "I'll push my team to finalize the agreements ASAP. Hopefully you will do the same."

Bush responded by e-mail that day, "I will do so. I got 146 days left in my job and want it to be finalized before I go."

But the deal wasn't finished before Bush left office at the end of 2006, and it still isn't.

Among the questions that remain is how much CSX would pay the state to run freight on the Orlando commuter track. Though the state would own the track, the agreement allowed CSX to use it during off-hours.

In December, DOT consulting lawyer John Bottcher questioned the fees the DOT team had proposed.

Bottcher's memo concluded: We "know that carriage of freight in and of itself provides a substantial public benefit. But there is a point where CSXT's profits would exceed the public benefit. I think FDOT's proposed fee structure is close to that point."

Contacted for this story, Bottcher said, "Much has changed since December." But he would not elaborate.

Nazih Haddad, one of the state rail officials working on the fee structure, said it is evolving.

The $491 million funding package for the CSX deal is part of the existing DOT budget and will not be taken before the Legislature for approval.

"This was all worked out behind closed doors, said state Rep. Bucher. "Most of us were kept in the dark."


Silent Governor

Florida's new governor, Charlie Crist, has said little about what he thinks of the CSX deal. Crist met with CEO Ward on April 17 to discuss it, among other topics, CSX confirmed.

Ward was to talk to Crist about the state's energy policies and how "both freight rail and passenger rail are good for the environment," CSX Vice President Lisa Mancini said in an e-mail to new DOT Secretary Stephanie Kopelousos.

Crist did not respond to several requests for comment.

Only recently did Polk County residents begin to sharply question the Winter Haven hub and its effects on the county. That prompted a significant development.

Last year, Bush's Department of Community Affairs allowed the hub to avoid a time-consuming, large-scale planning review of its effect on the area. A development of regional impact review can take several years.

But in May, the Polk County Commission asked the DCA to require the review.

It soon did, and alarms went off at the DOT. Ed Coven, one of the state officials involved in the negotiations, e-mailed Kopelousos to suggest the DCA didn't realize there was a connection between the hub and the Orlando commuter rail project.

That same day, DCA chief Tom Pelham announced his agency would work with CSX on a preliminary development agreement. That would allow CSX to do some construction on the hub while it undergoes the regional review.

Opposition continues to grow to CSX's plans in Polk County, particularly in Lakeland, where residents are circulating petitions asking for a meeting with Crist.

No meeting has been scheduled.


DEAL BREAKDOWN


In the state's deal with CSX, the state will pay:


•$198 million for upgrades on the CSX rail line between Baldwin and Plant City



•$150 million to buy 61 miles of CSX tracks between DeLand and Poinciana



•$59 million to build five road overpasses in Alachua, Sumter and Marion counties



•$52 million for work on other CSX lines across the state



•$23 million to help CSX move operations to Winter Haven from Orlando



•$9 million to build access roads to CSX's new rail hub in Winter Haven



The deal, which does not require the Legislature's approval, also affects South Florida's Tri-Rail commuter service. CSX has controlled maintenance and dispatching of the freight and passenger trains on the 81-mile corridor. But the agreement shifts that control to the South Florida Regional Transportation Authority.



WHAT COULD DERAIL THE PROPOSAL?


Before the CSX deal can be finalized, the Department of Transportation must perform an analysis to see whether the public is getting a good deal.

"We all understand that the public investment must be warranted based on public benefit," said DOT rail manager Fred Wise, who supervises the man who will do the analysis, Ed Lee.

Figuring out the public benefit is complex because the project has so many facets, Lee said. "It affects the entire state."

On the cost side, Lee will add up the tax money going to CSX and other factors such as lost revenue from property taken off the rolls and the cost of delays at crossings that will see more trains. Quality-of-life concerns are also supposed to be part of the ledger.

The benefits will include the number of vehicles taken off the road, any drop in highway spending, and the jobs created.

He conceded the analysis will include many assumptions: "This isn't an exact science." However, he declined to explain how he planned to figure out the debatable factors of the equation, such as how many people would give up their cars for the train.

But in the end, Lee said, he'll have a bottom-line number reflecting whether the public will gain more from the project than CSX.

If the public benefit isn't greater, he said, "there will be no deal."

Reporter Lindsay Peterson can be reached at (813) 259-7834 or lpeterson@tampatrib.com. Billy Townsend can be reached at (863) 284-1409 or btownsend@tampatrib.com.

http://www2.tbo.com/content/2007/sep/08/last-stop-rail-plan-tampa/?news-breaking

[Ocklawaha]

Interesting article Lake,
I tend to agree with Marion County, that they might get screwed in the process. Just a few years back they were the "models" for passenger rail rehabilitation and won big grants to rebuild Ocala Union Station into what might be the States first Transportation Center. Then Amtrak pulled the plug on the poorly scheduled Silver Star route through Ocala, and moved that train to the Orlando route.
A couple of observations:

The State DOT is stupid, they have allowed Seaboard System/CSX to rip up route after route by forcing their hand with high real estate taxes and swift abandonment applications. The former (recent) abandonments from Wildwood - Croom - Winter Haven would be worth it's weight in Gold right now... The TWO (Jacksonville) Gainesville - Dunnellon - Tampa lines would also be of great value... The Sanford - Trilby - St. Petersburg line would be of use in local passenger rail... The Orlando - Tavares - Wildwood segment could offer a passenger short cut to Ocala and Gainesville... Gainesville - Ocala - Leesburg - Trilby? Another alternate route that sits empty today... There is even another Tampa - Miami route via Bartow, but we let them cut that connection too... Rocket science guys...

I don't believe any passenger rail plan will work by missing Gainesville and Ocala, you can't cut the heart out of the beast and keep it running.

There is an alternate route from (Orlando) - Plant City -Tampa, CSX has probably not maintained it, but it is the former Seaboard Air Line Railroad mainline. It could be upgraded and used not only by Tampa, but also by Amtrak trains to access Tampa.

This is not a no-go situation, but we are going to have to get involved in relaying some routes, long gone. Freight volume has gone through the roof, doubled and trippled nationwide since the bad-old-days of the 1960's and 70's. Train volume hasn't kept pace due to new more powerful locomotives and longer freights. One has to ask how many trains ran over these lines in the 1940's at the height of WWII? In this new digital age, are they saying they can't do it now? HA!  

Ocklawaha

[thelakelander]

I don't believe any passenger rail plan will work by missing Gainesville and Ocala, you can't cut the heart out of the beast and keep it running.

It's either missing them or Metropolitan Orlando.  Either that or it's a passenger plan that has to have two N-S lines, meaning costs significantly rise.  If a plan had to be phased, you have to connect Orlando to Tampa first.  That corridor is one of the fastest growing in the state and would attract more riders than any other in Florida.  However, Tampa is right.  Once CSX runs the increased freight through Lakeland to Winter Haven's new rail hub, there's a slim chance of using that existing rail corridor for commuter rail purposes.

[Ocklawaha]

True but, the Ocala - Gainesville (Waldo) line already has the passenger stations and facilities in place, Amtrak just re-routed due to budget cuts. They could/SHOULD re start this if the new budget bill ever passes.

As for Orlando-Tampa, it's true that the curve plagued mainline is going to see lot's of new freight, mostly the Winter Haven - Lakeland segment. What they don't say is there are grades, some quite recent, that could re-route the freight off the passenger main and still accomplish the purpose. The old Seaboard cross-Florida mainline is in tact, from Tampa - Bartow - West Lake Wales, with only the Eastern most 5 miles or so abandoned. The old Atlantic Coast Line from Haines City to Lake Wales is in bits and pieces and was once a double track line. This grade leaves the Orlando - Tampa mainline just West of Disney. Since freight is more concerned with on-time delivery, then speed, it really doesn't matter that the freight could be routed around Lakeland. Reopening these little gaps plus the Croom - Auburndale - Winter Haven mainline (just abandoned) would fix the whole mess and make all of us better for the experience...

Go FDOT! Just remember they are JTA's daddy!

Ocklawaha

[Ocklawaha]

It's easy to see how with selective reconstruction, we could get around this problem without the fuss in Central Florida.

Purple lines are the former Atlantic Coast Line Mainlines (CSX)
Red lines are the former Seaboard Air Line Railroad (CSX)
Black are abandoned (most recently)

Ocklawaha

[thelakelander]

I grew up in Winter Haven.  Many of those lines have been abandoned since the mid 1980s.

1. The Bartow-Lake Wales link terminates at US 17 in Bartow.  From that point a line heads south parallel to US 17, down to Hardeeville to serve a couple of phosphate mines, a recently closed orange juice plant and a large lumberyard.

2. A piece of the Haines City-Lake Wales link was relayed a few years back for a concrete manufacturing facility near CR 544. 

There are several developments planned in this particular area, both between Bartow-Lake Wales and Lake Wales to Haines City (around Eagle Ridge Mall).  I doubt the railroad companies own most of that abandoned right-of-way today, but if something isn't done soon, it will be forever lost and replaced by apartments and single family tract housing. 

Other than that, cost wise, we're easily looking at spending over a billion to repurchase and relay track in that area.  If that's done, you then bypass Polk County's most urban and Central Florida's largest city between Tampa and Orlando, in Lakeland.

[Ocklawaha]

Great thoughts Lake, Yes, that's my whole argument, bypass Lakeland with most of the freight, the freight coming down from the A line, just rumbles across at Plant City and on to the old Seaboard. That would leave the Orlando-lakeland-Tampa line open for mixed freight and mostly passenger.

Like you said, we would have to spend some money to correct mistakes, but right now, it would be far cheaper then the long term of not having rail in place, having to build rail later or God forbid, freeways.  

Ocklawaha

[thelakelander]

Unfortunately, it would also bypass CSX's planned mega rail hub in Winter Haven. 

They'd be better off just laying rail in the middle of I-4, as proposed in the high speed rail plan Bush eliminated, if the existing CSX line through Lakeland can't be used for additional passenger rail.

There would be great free marketing for mass transit because people sitting in I-4 traffic jams would see the trains quickly pass them by.  It would be the same effect as not moving on the Gardiner Expressway in Toronto and watching the parallel GO Transit commuter rail trains blow by.

[Ocklawaha]

As both of us have lived a good number of years in Central Florida, I have to agree the effect of seeing trains blow past on I-4 would be tempting, but... They'd be empty if it was built like FOX wanted to do it. Orlando Airport down the Bee Line to I-4 to Tampa is a non route. NOBODY lives at Orlando Airport and they had no plan to take it onto local rail in the metro areas, something I considered a fatal flaw. I would look cool, but it would be like running to Waycross from JIA, who is going to ride? Even IF Waycross was as big as Tampa, by the time you drive to JIA, might as well drive to Waycross.

I'm just thinking if they reopened the Haines City - Lake Wales - Bartow - Tampa line, it would offer a great alternative route. Remember a rail car sitting in the yard, is a rail car that isn't making any money, so the trend is to pre-block trains to destinations. Sure the new yard will do classification of freight, but it won't break down every train that enters this part of Florida. The more that avoid it, the higher the profit. My guess is, it will do minimal class work, and mostly be a terminal for trailers (TOFC), containers and perhaps automobiles. There is a new Central Florida Automobile terminal North of Orlando on the Florida Central (former CSX) lines. I also doubt Winter Haven will have much effect on the Tampa yard, except for classification work. The arrivals and departures will still work out of there. Rock trains will still be sorted down in Mulberry and mostly run in Units to Rockport or Port Tampa anyway.

Rebuilding the old cut-off from West Lake Wales to Bartow would also re-open the old Cross-Florida Shortline route of the Seaboard Air Line. It gives us back the shortest rail route from Miami to Tampa.

In any case this is going to be interesting to watch, the State with it's head in the sand, doesn't get pro-active like Maryland, Michigan, Illinois, Nort Carollina, Vermont, California, New Mexico...etc... We always seem to be the one one sitting by the track watching the train go past. If FDOT would pull their heads out, we could have one heck of a system in ALL of Florida. As you have said, building on what we already have.

Ocklawaha

[thelakelander]

I always considered it should have been a local priority to tie in with the FOX system.  In Tampa that line would went through downtown and Ybor and could have connected to their streetcar.  In Orlando that line would have connected with their proposed light rail line before heading to the airport.  In Miami it would have connected to both the Metrorail and Tri-rail.  Anyway, I agree if this State can ever get its act right, we could put on heck of a mass transit system together.